Around 11 at night I opened my swollen inbox to take a closer look at what was being ordered. Everyone was ordering my “Are You Afraid of the Dark, Midnight Society” shirt. Something was up. I normally don’t sell too many of these. I decided to email one of my customers to ask them what was going on. They gladly informed me that the shirt made “Buzzfeed” titled, “18 Cool Etsy Products all ’90s Nickelodeon Kids Need Now.” Number 10!